Legal needs

Last modified: 2026-11-20 02:42by Erik Hagen ID: 0b82b987-237b-4fd7-bbac-5d3c7f2f056d SAMT-X/samt-bu-pilot-4

This page reproduces the pilot’s legal assessment “Pilot 4: Making results from education available – Legal assessment” (Sikt, deliverable from work package 3 “Overview of legal needs”). Translated from Norwegian; quoted statutory provisions are unofficial translations.

Problem statement

The SAMT-BU project group (“Seamless services for children and young people”) is working on how results from primary and lower secondary school and upper secondary education can be made available in a better and more coherent way to actors who need them for the further follow-up of young people. In this context, results means grades, status of completed education and training, competence, assessments or documentation of the level achieved. Since Sikt is working towards a national register of diplomas and results, tertiary vocational education (fagskole), higher education, and continuing and further education outside traditional public education are also included.

Today, results from primary and lower secondary school and upper secondary education are spread across several systems and in different formats. This document presents the legal needs for achieving simplified sharing of results from primary and lower secondary school and upper secondary education.

Diplomas from upper secondary education are registered digitally in the National Diploma Database (Nasjonal vitnemålsdatabase, NVB), whereas diplomas from primary and lower secondary school are prepared in municipal school administration systems and then shared as a file with Vigo. Otherwise, diplomas are mainly issued to pupils on paper. As a result, many (former) pupils do not have access to digital documentation of their entire education, and there is no single, authoritative source for this information. A register or database in which the information is collected in a digital format is therefore desirable.

This document presents the legal needs that must be addressed in order to achieve simplified and comprehensive digital sharing of results from the entire course of education. It is limited to questions of legal basis and the framework for data protection; technical and organisational matters are discussed only where they are of direct legal significance.

This chapter describes the need for a single database, the current legal bases and the existing basis for sharing and storing results.

The need for a single database

In today’s knowledge society, the labour market is undergoing rapid change and working life is becoming ever more knowledge-intensive. White Paper 14 (2022/23) Utsyn over kompetansebehovet i Norge (Outlook on Norway’s competence needs) describes how we as a society need a more productive workforce and the competence to carry out the green transition, and that a well-educated population is part of our insurance for the future.

The Norwegian Committee on Skill Needs (Kompetansebehovsutvalget) points out that restructuring in working life means that employees must develop their own competence throughout their careers. Competence in this context includes not only formal education, but also shorter courses, certifications and acquired prior learning (realkompetanse). It is therefore considered a problem that we do not have a fully-fledged national competence register with results from the entire course of education, which also includes competences and qualifications acquired outside the formal education system.

Once work is started to ensure better and more coherent access to results for children and young people, this work should be extended to cover a lifelong perspective. This will ensure an overall picture of competence in the population and access to one’s own results; strengthen coherent services and automation (efficiency gains in, among others, Lånekassen, Samordna opptak and HMS); provide access to statistics and support for societal planning; prevent loss of documentation in bankruptcies etc.; facilitate student mobility and integration with EU initiatives such as the digital identity wallet, along with other technical benefits; and yield economic gains.

Level of educationLegal basis for storing results (NVB)The register as authoritative source of resultsLegal basis for display in the diploma portalLegal basis for storage format
Primary and lower secondary school(needs legal basis)(needs legal basis)(needs legal basis)Opplæringsforskrifta § 9-45
Upper secondary educationOpplæringslova § 25-2(needs legal basis)Opplæringslova § 25-2Opplæringsforskrifta § 9-54
Tertiary vocational colleges (fagskoler)Fagskoleloven § 41(needs legal basis)Fagskoleloven § 41
Universities and university colleges(needs legal basis)(needs legal basis)UH-loven § 15-1

Opplæringslova is the Education Act, opplæringsforskrifta the regulations to the Education Act, fagskoleloven the Tertiary Vocational Education Act, and UH-loven (universitets- og høyskoleloven) the Universities and University Colleges Act.

Existing basis for sharing and storing results

The National Diploma Database (NVB)

Regulation in acts and regulations

Opplæringslova (the Education Act) § 25-2 provides the following legal basis for a database of diplomas and other documentation of competence achieved in upper secondary education:

§ 25-2. The national database for diplomas and other documentation of competence achieved in upper secondary education

The national database for diplomas and other documentation of competence shall facilitate

a. the collection of truthful information about, and the retention of, diplomas and other documentation of competence achieved in upper secondary education

b. verification that the diplomas have been validly completed in accordance with applicable rules

c. admission to higher education and to tertiary vocational education

d. sharing of diplomas and other documentation of competence

County authorities and others who provide upper secondary education shall, notwithstanding the duty of confidentiality, submit all diplomas and certificates of competence from upper secondary education to the database. The Ministry may by regulation lay down exceptions from this obligation.

The database may also contain diplomas and other documentation of competence from other education and training to the extent that this serves to fulfil one or more of the purposes in the first paragraph.

The database may automatically share a person’s national identity number or D number, and information about which documentation of the person’s competence the database contains, with a portal for sharing diplomas and documentation of competence, cf. the Universities and University Colleges Act § 15-1. Diplomas and documentation of competence may only be shared when the data subject has so decided.

The Ministry may issue regulations on the processing of personal data in the database, including on the purpose of the processing, controllership, what data may be processed and about whom, and access to, further processing and disclosure of personal data.

Furthermore, opplæringsforskrifta (the regulations to the Education Act) § 20-6 specifies the following:

Sikt – Norwegian Agency for Shared Services in Education and Research is the controller for the national database for diplomas and other documentation of competence achieved in upper secondary education. The data in the database may be used as a basis for analysis, statistics and research.

Current use of NVB

The purpose of establishing the database was to make admission to higher education more efficient, by facilitating automated processing of applications for admission and automatic quality assurance of diplomas. This is done through a dedicated control program. The data are also disclosed to Statistics Norway (SSB) and used for developing the admission services.

Opplæringslova § 25-2 continues § 3-14 of the former Act.1 The provision regulates the national database for diplomas and documentation of competence (NVB), and obliges providers of upper secondary education to submit diplomas and certificates of competence to the database. This also includes private schools, cf. privatskolelova (the Independent Schools Act) § 7-10. Today, it is primarily diplomas from upper secondary education that are entered in NVB.

Under opplæringslova § 25-2 second paragraph, certificates of competence shall be submitted to NVB. In practice this is not done. This is a discrepancy between the rules and practice which, as we understand it, stems from a lack of technical facilitation both in NVB and for mandatory deliveries from school administration systems. This should be facilitated, and we also refer to the Ministry’s statement in the preparatory works that “it is important that the database contains all types of documentation of competence achieved in Norwegian upper secondary education. This is important both for use in coordinated admission, to prevent document forgery and for archiving purposes.”2

The third paragraph allows “diplomas and other documentation of competence from other education and training” to be entered in NVB, as long as this fulfils one or more of the purposes listed in the first paragraph. According to the preparatory works (Prop. 57 L (2022–2023) p. 65), diplomas from tertiary vocational colleges may be entered in the database. Since the database may also contain documentation from “other education and training” if this fulfils one or more of the purposes in the first paragraph, trade and journeyman’s certificates are also covered by the provision. There is therefore a legal basis for including both diplomas from tertiary vocational colleges and trade and journeyman’s certificates as “other documentation of competence achieved” in NVB.

The fourth paragraph makes it possible for NVB to connect to Vitnemålsportalen (the diploma portal) so that the data subject can share information about their competence via this portal. At present, Vitnemålsportalen is used only for sharing results from higher education, even though the legal basis for sharing results from upper secondary education is already in place, see further under Vitnemålsportalen.

NVB currently has a control engine that verifies diplomas. It checks whether they have been completed in accordance with applicable standards: the control engine compares the diploma data against the applicable curriculum rules and recording rules laid down by the Norwegian Directorate for Education and Training (Udir). The control engine will not be part of the new register, but will continue as an independent service.

The Ministry’s assessment of data protection in NVB

In connection with the proposal to introduce a provision on the use of NVB,3 the data protection consequences of the register were assessed. It was concluded that the processing of personal data in NVB does not constitute an intrusive threat to the privacy of the individual data subject, and that the solution entails major benefits, see Prop. 145 L (2020–2021). Sikt – Norwegian Agency for Shared Services in Education and Research was designated as controller for the database in opplæringsforskrifta § 20-6. It is specified that the data may be used for analysis, statistics and research.

Opplæringslova § 25-2 allows the database to share national identity numbers/D numbers and information about the documentation of competence the database contains through a portal for sharing diplomas and competence, cf. the Universities and University Colleges Act § 15-1. This is what is today called Vitnemålsportalen, but which at present is used only for sharing results from higher education.

Vitnemålsportalen

Vitnemålsportalen is a digital sharing platform where individuals can retrieve their own results from higher education and share them with educational institutions, potential employers and other relevant third parties. When a user logs in to Vitnemålsportalen, the results are retrieved directly from the databases of the educational institutions where the person has studied.

The legal basis for sharing diplomas through the portal follows from universitets- og høyskoleloven (the Universities and University Colleges Act) § 15-1:

§ 15-1. Portal for sharing diplomas and documentation of competence

A portal for sharing diplomas and documentation of competence shall ensure truthful information about diplomas, grades, other documentation of competence achieved and decisions on recognition of foreign education and training. The portal shall also prevent the use of forged documents.

Personal data may be processed in the portal about persons who have diplomas, documentation of competence etc. registered with affiliated institutions, public administrative bodies, organisations and others. This applies insofar as those providing the data are permitted to share such information with the portal.

The data subject decides who shall have access to the information through the portal, what information they shall have access to, and for what period.

Documentation shared via the portal can only be verified in its original digital form.

The Ministry may issue regulations on the portal and on the processing of personal data, including on the purpose of the processing, controllership, what personal data may be processed and about whom, and on collection, further processing, disclosure of and access to personal data.

Sikt is responsible for operating the portal and is the controller for the data in the portal, cf. universitets- og høyskoleforskriften (the Regulations to the Universities and University Colleges Act) § 10-2.

Opplæringsloven § 25-2 makes it possible to use the portal for sharing results from upper secondary education, which in practice is not done today. In our assessment there is no legal obstacle to extending its use to upper secondary education; what mainly remains are technical adaptations on the part of Sikt/NVB, and a clarification of what status the digital documentation is to have (see valid documentation of competence achieved).

Prerequisites for lawful and effective storage and sharing

Digital diplomas and certificates of competence must be valid documentation of competence achieved

To achieve SAMT-BU’s goal of making results from primary and lower secondary school and upper secondary education available in a better and more coherent way, digital diplomas and certificates of competence must be regarded as valid documentation of competence achieved. This is also a measure against forgery of this type of documentation, in addition to digitalisation being necessary both when organisations are to automate processes and when the results are eventually to be included in the EU digital wallet.4

Diplomas from primary and lower secondary school and upper secondary education are currently issued to pupils on paper. Udir annually publishes guidelines for completing certificates of competence for primary and lower secondary school5 and upper secondary education.6 For both primary and lower secondary school and upper secondary education, the guidelines state that forms laid down by Udir are to be used, which must be ordered, completed and stamped. Duplicates must also be stamped.7 There are no corresponding guidelines for higher education. There, diplomas are as a rule issued digitally.

Udir’s guidelines have been interpreted to mean that diplomas and certificates of competence must be on physical paper and stamped to count as valid diplomas, and not merely a copy of the diploma. In our assessment, however, it does not follow from the legislation that paper format is a requirement for a diploma or certificate of competence to be valid as documentation of completed competence, see opplæringsforskriften § 9-45 and § 4-54.

As follows from opplæringslova § 25-2, the database shall facilitate the collection of truthful information and retention, verification of valid completion, admission to education and sharing of results. The preparatory works to amendments to the Education Act8 elaborate that the portal should also ensure that diplomas for which there was no archiving obligation (e.g. independent/private schools) would not be lost. The purpose of NVB presupposes that the digital version has evidential value; already today, the NVB registration is used as documentation for admission to higher education. Through the NVB system, the Ministry has thus already recognised that digital diplomas can be valid documentation for certain purposes.

Current practice and technical solutions mean that it will be difficult to have digital diplomas and other documentation of competence as the only valid document format for competence achieved.9 Even if the documentation is to be digital, paper diplomas must be able to be an alternative to, and on an equal footing with, paper diplomas when this is necessary.

It will be possible to have a “fully digital” solution where the main rule is that all diplomas are issued digitally. However, this presupposes a person-centric education ID, see Person-centric education ID, but it cannot be ruled out that there will be cases where a former pupil needs verified paper documentation (e.g. in connection with admission to studies abroad). We therefore currently consider that diplomas should not be issued exclusively digitally – we must allow paper documentation, at least as an exception.

It is thus considered that no amendment of the law is required to allow the use of digital diplomas, certificates of competence and other documentation as valid documentation of results achieved. For results in NVB to be recognised as valid documentation of results achieved, this presupposes a clarification in Udir’s guidelines for completing diplomas, certificates of competence and other documentation.

The impression must not be given that diplomas, certificates of competence and other documentation are valid as documentation of competence achieved only if they are completed in a way that can only be done on paper. An explicit statement should be included that digital registration in NVB (or in a corresponding register for primary and lower secondary school) is valid as documentation of competence achieved on a par with documentation on paper. At the same time, it should be considered whether Chapter 9 Parts VI and VII of opplæringsforskrifta should be updated with an explicit statement that the diploma is to be issued in digital form. Other provisions that should be considered for amendment include, for example, uhl. (the Universities and University Colleges Act) § 12-1 on the return of (paper) diplomas in certain cases.

Person-centric education ID

Today, a person’s identifier within education is linked to the institution the person is affiliated with. To achieve a functioning digital infrastructure around education in transitions between levels of education (and possibly when moving between municipalities), it is essential to be able to identify pupils. This can be handled by establishing a national service for identification of persons within education. A person-centric education ID would be a unique identifier linked to the individual, which could follow the pupil not only through their education but throughout their entire life.

This would address a number of practical problems with current identification arrangements, such as:

  • Refugees/asylum seekers and pupils without a national identity number or D number are not issued ID solutions linked to a personal identity number, such as BankID and MinID. Central ID arrangements are therefore unavailable to them.10
  • Some pupils do not have access to these ID solutions even though they have a national identity number/D number. There is an age limit of around 12–14 years for creating, for example, BankID and MinID. In addition, parental consent is required for persons under 18 to obtain BankID. Children can, however, order MinID on their own in the year they turn 13.11 Experience shows, however, that not all pupils manage to get this in place on their own before, for example, school admission etc. The Norwegian Digitalisation Agency (Digdir) is working to put in place a new arrangement, MinID for ungdom | DigiUng (MinID for young people). The aim is to have the issuance carried out in school, with a target of completion in 2026. As far as we are aware, the work is somewhat delayed.

The lack of a person-centric education ID has consequences, for example, when applying for upper secondary education via Vigo, where admission requires logging in with MinID or BankID. Pupils without a full digital identity may therefore encounter practical obstacles to exercising their right to upper secondary education under opplæringslova § 5-1. The same problem will arise when they later need to obtain access to documentation of results achieved.

A person-centric education ID can give the pupil a unique identifier linked to their education, which can be used for:

  • Logging in to education-related systems (Feide, learning platforms, application systems).
  • Linking data across municipal, county and central government systems.
  • Self-service access to one’s own results and diplomas via future sharing solutions.

Such an ID must be established with a legal basis. In our assessment there is not a sufficient basis in the current rules; neither opplæringslova § 25-1 (on the processing of personal data in general) nor § 25-3 (on obtaining information from the National Population Register) provides a legal basis for creating and managing a separate, education-specific personal identifier. A new provision must be established if this is to be introduced.

A person-centric education ID is a prerequisite for gaining the full benefit of developing the rules for storing and sharing results from children’s and young people’s education; a person-centric education ID should therefore be established in the longer term.

Processing of personal data requires a legal basis, cf. GDPR Article 6. A legal basis will be required for two different processing activities: storage of results and sharing of results. For storage in the register, consent is not considered particularly suitable.12 In our assessment, the most relevant legal basis is that the processing is necessary for the performance of a task carried out in the public interest or in the exercise of official authority vested in the controller, cf. GDPR Article 6(1)(e). According to Article 6(3), this presupposes that the basis for the processing is laid down by Union law or national law. Proposals for these bases are presented in the chapters on primary and secondary education and training, upper secondary education, controllership and higher education etc.

Sharing with third parties is somewhat different. Here the data subject is in a different position, actively wishing to share their results to obtain an advantage, such as admission to studies, employment etc. In such cases consent may be relevant. For sharing that is not initiated by the data subjects themselves, typically to Lånekassen, to Statistics Norway (SSB) for statistical purposes, or to other public institutions, consent is on the other hand not sufficient, and such sharing will probably need a legal basis in regulations with clear limits on the group of recipients, purpose and duration. For this type of sharing too, Article 6(1)(e) is considered the correct legal basis.

Needs per level of education

This chapter describes the need for legal bases for storing and sharing results at each level of education: primary and secondary education and training, upper secondary education, and higher education etc.

Primary and secondary education and training

A database for diplomas from primary and lower secondary school is necessary to ensure easy and better access to children’s results for actors who need them.

Since primary and lower secondary schools do not have common school administration systems (unlike, for example, higher education with FS), collecting diplomas in one place will enable future integration with the systems of other public actors that need access to the data (e.g. Lånekassen, SSB, NAV). Since the diplomas can then be retrieved from one single place, it will also make it possible for children to share their lower secondary school diplomas if an integration for this is built with Vitnemålsportalen.

Furthermore, it ensures robustness against loss of diplomas when schools are closed, municipalities are merged or computer systems are replaced. As for NVB, it can also counteract document forgery and manipulation of admission grounds.13

Below, alternatives are presented for ensuring a sufficient legal basis for establishing such a database.

Extending opplæringslova § 25-2

Opplæringslova § 25-2 obliges providers of upper secondary education to submit diplomas to NVB. An amendment to § 25-2 third paragraph also obliging providers of primary and lower secondary education to submit diplomas to NVB would be a sufficient legal basis for storing results from primary and lower secondary school. Of the proposals that require new legal bases to be established or the law to be amended, this solution is probably the most time-saving.

An alternative could be to regulate the right to store (and share) results in separate regulations. We consider this particularly relevant if a more complete overview of education documentation is pursued, one that also includes higher education. This is described below under Act or regulations on a database for competence.

Extending opplæringslova § 25-2 to also cover results from primary and lower secondary school will mean that the results can also be shared in Vitnemålsportalen, cf. § 25-2 fourth paragraph. According to the provision, the database “may” “share a person’s national identity number or D number and information about which documentation of the person’s competence […]” in NVB with Vitnemålsportalen. This information is necessary for Vitnemålsportalen to function as a platform for sharing results.

To ensure that pupils can in practice make use of the sharing portal, the statutory text must require that the information “shall” be shared with Vitnemålsportalen.

The portal should also be able to share information with institutions and organisations that have a legal basis for obtaining diplomas and similar documentation from NVB. Even if some have a legal basis for obtaining documentation from NVB, NVB needs a legal basis for processing in order to lawfully disclose the results. It would then be appropriate to lay down in law the obligation to share the information. The legal basis will be as discussed under Processing of personal data requires a legal basis. Such a provision should be worded in the same way as universitets- og høyskoleforskriften § 10-2 (2).

Upper secondary education

Upper secondary education within the meaning of the Education Act also includes apprenticeship in a company,14 and trade and journeyman’s certificates are to be issued as documentation of a passed trade or journeyman’s examination, cf. opplæringsforskrifta § 9-48. As mentioned earlier, there is already a clear legal basis for storing diplomas from upper secondary education in NVB. The provision does not explicitly mention trade and journeyman’s certificates.

It is the county authority that issues trade or journeyman’s certificates. As mentioned under Current use of NVB, we consider that trade and journeyman’s certificates are covered by “other documentation of competence from other education and training”, which the database may contain, cf. opplæringslova § 25-2 third paragraph.

For the database to function as a complete and authoritative source of documentation from primary and secondary education, it should become a requirement that trade and journeyman’s certificates be submitted to NVB, in the same way as diplomas and certificates of competence. This can be achieved by having the second paragraph of the provision explicitly also cover trade and journeyman’s certificates.

Graduated pupils cannot themselves share their diplomas digitally from NVB. The legal basis in opplæringsloven § 25-2, which allows documentation of competence achieved to be shared through a portal, means that there is no legal obstacle to extending today’s Vitnemålsportalen to also be used for documentation from upper secondary education. This presupposes technical adaptations on the part of NVB. The pupil can then share their results whenever they wish. However, as mentioned under Legal basis for sharing results from primary and lower secondary school, a requirement to share certain information with Vitnemålsportalen should be considered so that pupils have a real possibility of sharing.

As for results from primary and lower secondary school, the portal should also be able to share information with institutions and organisations that have a legal basis for obtaining diplomas and similar documentation from NVB. Even if some have a legal basis for obtaining documentation from NVB, NVB needs a legal basis for processing in order to lawfully disclose the results. It would then be appropriate to lay down in law the obligation to share the information. The legal basis will be as discussed under Processing of personal data requires a legal basis. Such a provision should be worded in the same way as universitets- og høyskoleforskriften § 10-2 (2).

Higher education etc.

Universities and university colleges

To achieve a single database for documentation of competence, results from higher education must also be included in the database. Universities and university colleges must therefore be required by law to submit documentation of competence to the database. This can be done in the same form as in opplæringslova § 25-2, either in a separate provision in the Universities and University Colleges Act or its regulations, or possibly in a single regulation for a database of results, see Act or regulations on a database for competence.

Tertiary vocational colleges

At present, results from tertiary vocational colleges are not in NVB.15 As mentioned earlier in the document, for tertiary vocational colleges we already have a legal basis for storing documentation in opplæringsforskrifta § 25-2 third paragraph, cf. fagskoleloven (the Tertiary Vocational Education Act) § 41. However, like the corresponding provision for “other documentation of competence”, this legal basis is voluntary. To give a complete picture of the individual’s competence, providers of tertiary vocational education should be required to submit diplomas to the database.

We are aware that several tertiary vocational colleges do not use computer systems to record grades and diplomas, but Excel spreadsheets. A requirement to submit diplomas to NVB therefore presupposes that the colleges get a system that facilitates this. The structure of NVB is being updated so that tertiary vocational colleges will be able to send results through integration with our API.

A legal basis must also be established for sharing the results, corresponding to the Universities and University Colleges Act § 15-1.

Continuing and further education outside traditional public education

Voksenopplæringsloven (the Adult Education Act) § 10 regulates the issuing of course certificates for adults who have attended courses under the study association scheme. Kompetanseforbundet, which organises the approved study associations under the Ministry of Education and Research, is currently running pilots on competence certificates. This is an official, digital proof that a person has completed and passed a competence assessment, and it documents a person’s skills and knowledge in a specific area. It is verified through a unique QR code and verification number that employers can scan or confirm on a verification page. Kompetanseforbundet regards itself as processor on behalf of the study associations, which are controllers, and participants can request that certificates be deleted.

In our assessment there are good reasons to include documentation from the study association scheme in a national competence register.16 We propose, however, that the register be limited to course certificates issued by study associations approved under the Adult Education Act. This prevents the register from becoming too extensive, and ensures that the documentation is issued by actors with a legally regulated responsibility. Courses and certifications that fall outside the study association scheme are kept out in the first instance.

Such a solution requires two legal bases that are currently lacking:

  1. Legal basis for storage: The Adult Education Act should be supplemented with a provision obliging approved study associations to submit course certificates to NVB (corresponding to the submission obligation for upper secondary education in opplæringslova § 25-2 second paragraph). The fact that participants can currently request deletion of certificates is hardly compatible with the ambition of an authoritative and as complete as possible competence register, and should be addressed in the legislative work.
  2. Legal basis for sharing: A legal basis should be established for sharing course certificates from the study association scheme via Vitnemålsportalen, corresponding to the sharing provision in the Universities and University Colleges Act § 15-1. Sharing should take place on the data subject’s own initiative, following the same model as for other documentation of competence in the portal.

Controllership

In addition to the challenges concerning the legal basis for processing results through storage in databases and sharing in Vitnemålsportalen, there is the question of who is to be regarded as controller for these processing operations. We have tried to point out some issues relating to this below.

Controllership for storing diplomas in the database

For NVB, opplæringsforskrifta § 20-6 specifies that Sikt is the controller for the database. It further specifies that the data in the database may be used as a basis for analysis, statistics and research. This can be interpreted to mean that the content of the diplomas, and controllership for it, lies with the school owners (or tertiary vocational colleges) that originally transferred the diplomas to NVB, and that Sikt is the processor. However, this has not been discussed or specified anywhere, and needs further examination. If the schools were to be controllers, it should be decided who takes over this responsibility if an institution is closed down.

When diplomas are completed, they are sent through a control engine to check that they have been completed correctly.17 This also happens when the diplomas are transferred to NVB. We cannot see that it has been decided who is the controller for this processing or what the legal basis for processing is, but since the control engine is to be separated from NVB, we will not go into this further.

Controllership for Vitnemålsportalen

Under universitets- og høyskoleforskriften § 10-2 third paragraph, Sikt is the controller for the personal data in the portal. There is a limited amount of personal data in the portal itself (national identity number/D number and the organisations where the person has results), since the diplomas are not stored in the portal. We have no comments on this.

Concluding remarks

Act or regulations on a database for competence

As mentioned earlier, one alternative for providing a legal basis for the right to store and share results is a separate act or regulation. Regulations can be issued pursuant to several acts. This would be particularly appropriate if a database is to be established with as complete an overview as possible of the individual’s competence. First, the provisions on recording results, issuing and transfer to the database will be technical, and it can be argued that this is somewhat beside what is already regulated in the acts on education and competence. Second, it will provide greater flexibility if the provisions need to be changed, rather than having to amend several individual acts and regulations.

The database must be an authoritative source of results

It must be a goal that the diplomas in NVB, and other documentation that may in future be included in the database, are regarded as authoritative sources of documentation of results achieved. This means that the database is to be the primary place from which various actors retrieve results or have them verified. This presupposes that the database has integrity, reflects reality, is available and contains all the competence that has been decided to be included.

For digital diplomas and certificates of competence to be authoritative, there must be technical solutions that ensure that the documentation in NVB is up to date at all times. The current solution for submitting diplomas from upper secondary education to NVB means that the schools send a file to the system, which is a copy of the diploma held in the school’s own systems.18 If the school makes changes to the diploma, for example due to an appeal, annulment or correction, the school must send the annulment of the old diploma and the new diploma to NVB. Only if we can ensure that the documentation in NVB is up to date at all times can the diplomas and other documentation be regarded as authoritative sources.

Furthermore, the legal bases must be designed so that providers of primary and secondary education, higher and tertiary vocational education, and other continuing and further education are required to share results with the database. This ensures that all results are found in one place.

Sufficient technical solutions must be established to ensure the integrity of the results that are shared, and to facilitate sharing, retrieval and verification.


  1. https://lovdata.no/lov/1998-07-17-61/§3-13 ↩︎

  2. Prop. 145 L (2020–2021) - regjeringen.no chap. 2.4.7.5 (in Norwegian). ↩︎

  3. Prop. 145 L (2020–2021) - regjeringen.no chap. 2.4.7 (in Norwegian). ↩︎

  4. Implementering av eIDAS 2.0 | Samarbeidsportalen (Implementation of eIDAS 2.0, in Norwegian) ↩︎

  5. Føring av vitnemål og kompetansebevis for grunnskolen i Kunnskapsløftet – 2026 | udir.no (Completing diplomas and certificates of competence for primary and lower secondary school, in Norwegian) ↩︎

  6. Føring av vitnemål og kompetansebevis for videregående opplæring i Kunnskapsløftet – 2026 | udir.no (Completing diplomas and certificates of competence for upper secondary education, in Norwegian) ↩︎

  7. See chap. 1 for primary and lower secondary school and chap. 2 for upper secondary education. ↩︎

  8. Prop. 145 L (2020–2021) - regjeringen.no chap. 2.4.7.5 (in Norwegian). ↩︎

  9. For example, foreign pupils may need a paper printout, and some educational institutions abroad may require paper diplomas as part of the admission process. ↩︎

  10. As NOAS (Norwegian Organisation for Asylum Seekers) documents in Rikets tilstand 2024, chapter “Usikker oppholdsstatus” (Uncertain residence status): “Young people do not complete upper secondary school because, as apprentices, they depend on a driving licence and a bank account, and parents cannot have ordinary communication with kindergarten/school that requires BankID or another eID at a high security level for logging in to online information solutions.” ↩︎

  11. Bruk MinID for å logge deg inn | Norge.no (Use MinID to log in, in Norwegian) ↩︎

  12. GDPR Article 8 and personopplysningsloven (the Personal Data Act) § 5 set a lower age limit of 13 years for children’s consent in relation to information society services. Most people who have a diploma will be around 15 years old. Nevertheless, it is, first, impractical to obtain valid consent from all pupils, especially if all children are to have access to their diplomas for a long time to come. Storage should then be mandatory. In addition, there is an imbalance of power between pupils and schools which makes consent unsuitable. ↩︎

  13. Prop. 145 L (2020–2021) - regjeringen.no chap. 2.4.7.5 (in Norwegian). ↩︎

  14. Prop. 57 L (2022-2023) chap. 69, comment on § 1-2 (1) ↩︎

  15. Apart from a couple of tertiary vocational colleges that qualify as university colleges. ↩︎

  16. First, it contributes to a more complete picture of the individual’s competence throughout life; the labour market increasingly demands prior learning and experience (realkompetanse). Second, the study associations are approved by law and subject to supervision and control, which ensures a minimum level of quality both in the educational offering and in the documentation issued. This distinguishes study association courses from unregulated private course providers and makes it justifiable to include the documentation in a public register. ↩︎

  17. Prop. 145 L (2020–2021) - regjeringen.no chap. 2.4.7.1 (in Norwegian). ↩︎

  18. An API that is to replace this solution in the future is under development. ↩︎